• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Winnie's (Soul Food) – Authentic Southern Comfort Food in Amityville, NY

Winnie's (Soul Food), nestled in Amityville, NY, serves up soulful, heartfelt dishes that capture the essence of traditional Southern cooking with a modern twist. Their Mac and Cheese, praised for perfect seasoning and creamy richness, stands out alongside comforting classics like Jerk Chicken, Pork Chop Dinner, and Candied Yams. The Lobster Shrimp Mac and Cheese offers a luxurious take on a beloved staple, while dishes like Rasta Pasta deliver vibrant Caribbean flavors. Friendly service and a warm atmosphere make Winnie's a standout on Long Island’s soul food scene, where passion and authenticity come together on every plate.

Winnie's (Soul Food) at a glance

  • Address 655 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, United States
  • Restaurant type Soul food restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Winnie's (Soul Food): Reviews & Ratings

Claire Campbell
5

Amazing!! Staff was so friendly. Mac and Cheese was perfectly seasoned and so delicious!

Isis Chestnut
4

First time eating here, i finally made the stop and i am happy i did. One person taking orders but she works and is very nice, you can tell a lot of people go there on the usual because its very personable...Yams and Lobster mac and cheese...my oh my!!!

Sarah F
5

Was here a while ago when it was a different cook/name/company. Remembered food was delicious. Different owners, different tastes, same deliciousness.

Nik Nunya
5

The food is AMAZING & Terrence is such a beautiful kind soul with a lot of passion. He gave the best service & I can honestly say that this is something harder & harder to come by especially in such a tough industry. God bless to all of the people making this food homemade too

Places Days
5

Well as you all may know, it’s hard to find a good soul food place on Long Island. I was pleasantly surprised at how good this place is. The only issue I had was the styrofoam to go containers but it’s not like I can’t take it out of the plate. Loved it and hope to keep going. Forgot to take a before picture.

Louis Vee
4

Good food, I had the jerk chicken with Mac n cheese and it was delicious The staff was very friendly, asked me if it was my first time there, took the time to explain the menu items and the way ordering works which I really appreciated. Not giving it 5 stars because it's a bit pricey in my honest opinion. I can go to a Spanish deli, get similar food/amount for half the price.

Hannah Conlon
5

Wow, the fried pork chops were so delicious and the fried chicken as well. Flavor packed in the Mac and the greens. Customer service is on point and I will be coming back!!!

Misou J
5

Where do I begin....the food is AMAZING. I have never had collard greens like this before. It wasn't bitter at all, which I don't and wouldn't mind but this was unique, bursting with flavor. It had a little zing, a little spice, some heat, sweetness (probably honey), and some fresh acidity to cleanse the palette for the next bite. The Mac "n" Cheese was baked to perfection. It was everything you want Mac "n" Cheese to be. It was creamy, very cheesy, not overly salty, and very savory. I got ribs (since they were out of chicken) and boy did it not disappoint. It was firm but tender, simple but leaving you wanting more after each bite. And the service was superb. The guy working tonight was the owners son. Very kind, honest, and considerate. He even gave me a free piece of sweet potato corn bread and promised it was good, and he definitely didn't lie. My three older who doesn't really eat cornbread ate it up. I give this place a 10/10 and will be frequenting here often. Thanks for an amazing meal and no they did not ask me to write this review and no I don't work here. Just believing not gatekeeping and writing honest reviews. Check them out, you'll see for yourself.

Location

  • Winnie's (Soul Food)
    Winnie's (Soul Food)
    655 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, United States

Winnie's (Soul Food) in Amityville, NY, is a true gem for anyone craving authentic soul food that speaks to the heart and palate. Nestled at 655 Broadway, this welcoming spot offers a menu that proudly showcases classic Southern comfort dishes, elevated with rich flavors and heartfelt preparation.

The star here is undoubtedly the Mac and Cheese, which customers repeatedly praise for its perfect seasoning and creamy texture. Whether paired with crispy fried chicken or the decadent lobster shrimp variation, this dish never fails to impress. The Pork Chop Dinner delivers a tender, juicy experience that feels both nostalgic and satisfying. Equally noteworthy are the candied yams and corn on the cob, which provide a sweet and savory balance, rounding out a soul food feast that celebrates homestyle cooking.

Winnie's also shines with its jerk chicken and the vibrant Rasta Pasta Shrimp, dishes infused with Caribbean flair that add exciting, spicy undertones to the menu. The fusion of traditional soul food with subtle island influences creates a unique dining experience, making each visit memorable.

From the friendly service led by passionate staff like Terrence to the warm, personable atmosphere, Winnie's fosters a sense of community that elevates the meal beyond just food. This is a place where soulful cooking meets genuine care, making every bite a comfort and joy. For those on Long Island searching for authentic, well-crafted soul food, Winnie's is a standout destination that deserves your attention.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments